Monday, January 21, 2013
Tamar, a Novel of Espionage, Passion and Betrayal by Mal Peet
The story then switches to 1945, introducing Dart and Tamar, undercover names (based on English rivers) for two Dutch born, British trained agents for the SOE (Special Operations Executive) just as they are about to parachute into the Nazi-occupied Netherlands to work with the Dutch Resistance in an attempt to reorganize it during that terrible Hunger Winter when so many people died of starvation. Once inside Holland, Dart, who is the team's radio operator, operates under the name Dr. Ernest Lubbers, living and setting up his radio at the local mental asylum. Tamar, under the name of Christiaan Boogart, is fortunate enough to be placed in the home of Marijke Maatens. Tamar/Christiaan and Marijke have been lovers for a while, but when Dart/Lubbers realizes what is going on between them, he becomes very angry and jealous. He has also fallen in love with Marjike.
The narrative moves to the spring of 1995. Jan Hyde's daughter Tamar Hyde is now 15. Her father has be missing for a few years and her beloved grandmother, Marijke, has recently passed away, after being placed in a nursing home because she was seemingly suffering from dementia. Now, her grandfather has just committed suicide. As a result of that, Tamar finds herself in possession of a box full of his World War II memorabilia. Tamar knew that her Grandad "was fascinated by riddles and codes and conundrums of labyrinths, by the origin of place names, by grammar, by slang, by jokes...by anything that might mean something else. He lived in a world that was slippery, changeable, fluid." (pg 111) And so Tamar begins a journey to figure out that codes messages her Grandad has left regarding his life and suicide.
From here on the story alternates between 1945 and 1995 as events unfold and characters are explained. I don't want to say too much more at this point and risk an unintended spoiler, which can so easily happen with suspense novels you feel enthusiastic about.
Tamar is an exciting, suspenseful, very sophisticated and often gritty YA novel, but it is definitely not going to be everyones cup of tea. A lot of readers said they had a hard time getting into the story, while others complained that it was big (379 pages) and too slow moving, while other readers thought it was a 5 star story. I tend to be on the side of the 5 star folks.
Peet's teenage narrator proves to be quite formidable. One would almost think beyond her 15 years, but given Tamar's life experiences so far, maybe her formidability is completely understandable. Through her voice, Peet details her discoveries in a very straightforward style, clean and clear, yet it is all done in such lyrical prose that sometimes it often made me almost forget the subtext of the title. Without my realizing that he had done it, Peet has taken that subtext espionage, passion and betrayal, wound and woven them together in a story that left me unsuspecting until the very end and then totally surprised. In fact, after I finished it, I thought the whole novel is really a reflection of of William Hyde's love of all things enigma and that, I think, that is what makes Tamar such an unusual story. And yet, all along the way, Tamar gives us innocent (?) hints about where things are going.
The book is recommended for readers age 14+
This book was bought for my personal library
Walker Books Australia has a very nice teacher's guide here.
This book was awarded the following well-deserved honors:
2005 Carnegie Medal
206 Wirral Paper Back of the Year
2008 ALA's Top Ten Best Books for Young Adults
2011 De Gouden Lijst
This is book 4 of my 2013 Historical Fiction Reading Challenge hosted by Historical Tapestry
This is book 2 of my 2013 European Reading Challenge hosted by Rose City Reader
Posted by Alex Baugh at 9:57 AM
Labels: Dutch Resistance, England, Family, Friendship, Spies, YA
Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)
This novel has been on my wishlist for a while. From your review, I think you'd definitely be recommending it to me. Thanks, Alex.ReplyDelete
It was really a good novel, along the line of Code Name Verity.ReplyDelete
Sounds like a good read. I love novels set during WWII, or immediately thereafter.ReplyDelete
New Follower. Please visit my blog when you have the time.
P. G. Shriver
This is good, and yes, I will come over and visit your blog.Delete
How exciting that there is a twist at the end! It sounds very intriguing and I can't wait to find out what happens. Another book to add to my list. :)ReplyDelete
Yes, I liked the twist, it made the story that much more interesting. I hope you enjoy it.Delete
I've seen a lot of praise for this book recently, but even within that this is a particularly enticing review. Thank you.ReplyDelete
Thanks, it is a great book. I hope you get around reading it.Delete
By the sound of your review, I think the story would hook a few of my older students. Thanks for bringing it to my attention.ReplyDelete
Fabulous review and the book sound great- definitely want to read it so that's another for the list. Thanks.
Definitely a 5 star read but one for mature YA readers. One of my favourite books.ReplyDelete
What an exciting book. Sounds very sophisticated and doesn't dumb itself down for its intended audience (as it should be).ReplyDelete
You make this sound very interesting. I'll have to look for it.ReplyDelete
You always find the best books! Your blog is a terrific resource -- I have recommended it to several people looking for good YA books.ReplyDelete
Thanks for including your review on the European Reading Challenge page.
Rose City Reader