You may also recall that author Kurt Vonnegut was a 23 year old prisoner of war in Dresden during the firebombing. In his introduction to Slaughterhouse Five Or The Children's Crusade, he recalls the difficulty he had trying to write this novel about the Dresden bombing, unable to find the words needed. As he says in his introduction "there is nothing intelligent to say about a massacre." (pg 19)
While thinking about these things on Friday, I recalled two picture books that I think both remind us of the destructive power of war and reinforce why it is such a terrible thing.
Why War is Never a Good Idea by Alice Walker, illustrated by Stefano Vitale
Harper Collins, 2007, 32 pages
Stefano Vitale's folk art painted illustrations take you around the world, showing how different places and people are impacted the same way by war and, as you can see, he nicely juxtaposes what the lush green world of peace looks like compared to what the destroyed gray world of war looks like:
The rhythmic text isn't always the best I've read by Walker, but certainly she gets her pacifistic ideas across, ideas I can completely agree with. What really makes this a moving, effective work is the combination of text and illustrations. Each stands better with the other than they would alone.
And, in the end, seeing faces looking down a poisoned water well, Walker poses the question to her reader - What if you become war? Certainly, food for thought.
The Enemy: a book about peace by Davide Cali, illustrated by Serge Bloch
Schwartz & Wade, 2009, 40 pages
The second book I pulled off my shelves when thinking about Dresden this week is a book written by Davide Cali and illustrated by Serge Bloch called The Enemy: a book about peace. I love this book. It says so much using so little. Two soldiers, sitting opposite each other in their separate foxholes, are enemies because their manuals told them they were enemies.
One solider claims his enemy isn't human, he's a beast, knows no mercy, will kill families, pets, burn down forests, poison water. Well, that's what the manual says, anyway. But sitting in a foxhole isn't easy - one gets hungry, it rains and becomes uncomfortable.
One day, the soldier disguises himself as a bush and leaves his hole, crawling towards his enemy so he can kill him and end the war. But when he gets there, what a surprise. His enemy is gone, but has left his things behind - family pictures and a manual that says his enemy isn't human - hmm, wait a minute! Where has he seen that before? Then, realizing his enemy has crawled over to his hole, the soldier sends outs a peace message to him at the same time the enemy sends one to him. Doesn't take much to figure out how this ends.
Bloch used simple, almost cartoonish pen and ink illustrations for The Enemy. The only colors are the khaki of the soldier's uniforms, red blood and the red cover of the manuals they used, though real photos were used for the enemy's family, bring the story close to home, so to speak. Such spare illustrations really forces the reader to focus on the words of the text, written in the first person by one soldier, which isn't favoritism for one side or the other because you know the other soldier is thinking the same thoughts.
These are definitely picture books for older readers. They are excellent and complimentary books about war and peace, each extending the other's message. Both of these books will or should generate conversations and questions by kids and it is advisable to judge the age and child's ability to tolerate these messages, however peaceful they may be meant.
And if you haven't already read Slaughterhouse Five, I highly recommend it. And have a peaceful day!
Both of these books are recommended for readers age 8+
Both of these books were purchased for my personal library
Thanks so very much for sharing books about peace. I was not familiar with either of these and would like to get them. I also have not read Slaughterhouse Five. So I do appreciate you steering me in that directions.ReplyDelete
At some level it seems to me that every book about war can also be viewed as a book about peace. Maybe not - I certainly haven't read them all but each one I do, makes me hate war even more.
I totally agree with you, Joyce, every book about war is a book about peace. I hope the more we read about how terrible war is, the less inclined we will be to wage it - but, alas, not everyone feels that way these days.Delete
I watched the coverage on TV and was shocked at just how terrible it all was. I’ve grown used to seeing photographs of London during the blitz so in many ways it felt more ‘real’ when looking at pictures of Dresden.ReplyDelete
The Enemy sounds like an incredible book and one I will be looking out for.